Plans to redevelop the former Wells Police Station have been delayed due to concerns over the lack of local car parking facilities.

Wells Police Station operated on the A39 Glastonbury Road until late 2021, when the police moved to their new facility inside the fire station on Burcott Road.

Churchill Retirement Ltd. put forward plans in August 2023 to convert the buildings into 47 extra care apartments, which came before the council's planning committee in Shepton Mallet on March 5.

But a decision has been pushed back by councillors for up to two months to allow for further negotiations over the amount of car parking on site and contributions for new affordable homes elsewhere in the city.

The site lies near numerous existing health and care facilities, including the Crandon Springs and Fletcher House care homes, the Wells Health Centre, Wells City Pharmacy and the St. Andrew's mental health ward.

Access will be from the existing entrance onto the A39, with 23 car parking places being provided on site. Of the new properties 31 will be one-bedroom flats and 16 will be two-bedroom flats, all of which will be sold at full market price to the over-60s.

Each of the flats will be able to access communal facilities within the complex, including an owners' lounge, guest suite and meeting areas.

The company already operates the Riverain Lodge complex in Taunton town centre, and has expressed an interest in redeveloping the Crispin Centre in Street into new apartments.

Both the Street and Wells sites have been provisionally allocated for development within the revised Mendip Local Plan Part II, which is currently out for public consultation.

The developer has faced numerous viability issues with the site, resulting from the ongoing phosphates crisis and high inflation within the construction industry, which has limited how much affordable housing could be delivered within the site itself.

The company originally offered to contribute £434,000 towards other affordable housing schemes in the city (whether council or developer-driven) but this has now been revised down to £100,000, on top of around £18,000 for new or expanded health facilities.

Councillor Edric Hobbs (who represents the neighbouring Mendip Hills division questioned whether 23 parking spaces would be sufficient given the number of elderly people in Somerset who still drive.

He said: "If we have all these elderly people in their eighties, all with their Honda Jazzes, there's not many parking spaces.

"I'd like to try and push for a few more parking spaces – I don't think this number, in a small city which already has a parking problem, is enough."

Councillor Bente Height (Shepton Mallet) agreed: "The equivalent of half a car parking space per dwelling is ridiculous. I'm very old and I still drive and rely on my car.

"These people will get visitors coming, at least just to check that they might be still alive. We are treating them as second-class citizens and that's not good enough – it is indecent to humanity."

Councillor Susannah Hart (Glastonbury) added: "If you're an 80-year-old widow who's fallen over, you won't be walking into town from there. You will either need someone to collect you, a taxi or a car.

"I hope we don't make these kinds of poor decisions about parking again moving forward."

The site lies within the Somerset Levels and Moors catchment area, meaning that additional mitigation has to be provided by the developer to prevent any net increase in phosphates within the catchment area.

To achieve this, the developer has agreed to purchase phosphate credits generated by fallowing agricultural land at Yew Tree Farm near Wraxall – the same site which was fallowed to unlock 280 new homes on the B3151 Somerton Road in Street.

Councillor Shane Collins (Frome East) said it was "appalling" that so little money was being provided for affordable housing, stating: "This doesn't give the people of Wells nearly enough.

"I don't want to see developers making huge amounts of money when they're not putting back into the community."

The committee voted to defer a decision until May at the latest by a margin of eight votes to one, with one abstention.

To give your views on the revised Mendip Local Plan Part II, visit www.somersetcouncil.citizenspace.com/planning/mendip-local-plan-part-ii-limited-update-reg-18 by April 12.